Choosing an approach
Reggio, Montessori and Waldorf, side by side.
Three of the most common approaches in early childhood, explained in plain terms. What each one believes about children, how a morning actually runs, and where each one may leave a child well prepared for a future none of us can quite picture.

At a glance
The short version, before the detail.
These are summaries, and every centre reads its own approach a little differently. The sections below take each one in turn.
Reggio Emilia
- What it believes about the child
- That the child is strong, capable and resilient, not an empty vessel waiting to be filled.
- How the day is shaped
- Long, open ended projects that follow the children’s questions, with real time in an art studio, the atelier.
- The adult’s role
- A co learner and researcher: observing, documenting, and offering a provocation rather than an answer.
- What it is reaching for
- Curiosity, problem solving and collaboration, and the hundred languages children use to express an idea.
- Often suits
- Children who want to make, test, and work alongside others on something that lasts.
Montessori
- What it believes about the child
- That the child is naturally driven to learn, given a carefully prepared room and the freedom to choose.
- How the day is shaped
- Uninterrupted work periods, with children choosing from materials prepared for them, alone or in small groups.
- The adult’s role
- A guide who prepares the room and observes closely, stepping back so the child can finish the work themselves.
- What it is reaching for
- Independence, concentration, order and confidence, built through real, hands on work.
- Often suits
- Children who settle to independent work, hold attention well, and take direction easily.
Waldorf
- What it believes about the child
- That play is the serious work of early childhood, and that imagination comes before instruction.
- How the day is shaped
- A steady weekly and seasonal rhythm, with practical work, crafts, stories, and long stretches of free play.
- The adult’s role
- More present and more directing, setting the themes, telling the stories, modelling the work.
- What it is reaching for
- Imagination, social and practical skill, and a felt relationship with nature and the seasons.
- Often suits
- Highly imaginative children who love nature, group play and make believe.
One at a time
Three approaches, in their own terms.
Each one is described here as its own practitioners would describe it. Where an approach is strong, we say so. Where a family might find a compromise, we say that too.
One approach
Reggio Emilia
Inquiry first. The curriculum is built with the children, not handed to them.
Reggio Emilia begins with a view of the child as strong, capable and resilient, rather than an empty vessel to be filled. The approach grew out of the municipal schools of Reggio Emilia in northern Italy after the Second World War, and it is still held as a way of thinking about children rather than a method with a fixed set of steps.
Projects are co constructed: children and teachers follow a question together for as long as it holds their interest. The room itself is treated as a teacher, arranged with intention. There is an atelier, a studio, where a specialist works with children in clay, paint, wire, light and natural materials. And there is documentation of what the children do, in photographs, transcripts and display, which makes their thinking visible to them and to the adults.
The teacher is a researcher and a co learner rather than a transmitter of content, and families are treated as partners in the work.
What it does well
- Sustained attention on something the child chose, carried for weeks rather than minutes.
- Comfort with open questions, and the confidence to work without one right answer.
- Collaboration, because the projects are usually shared.
- Many ways to express an idea, so a child who does not yet write can still show what they know.
What to weigh
- Less scripted than the other two. Families who want a predictable academic sequence should ask how literacy and numeracy are tracked.
- Quality leans heavily on staff skill and time, since documentation and co construction take real work.
- It looks different from centre to centre, which makes comparison harder.
One approach
Montessori
Independence, through real materials and a room prepared for the child.
Maria Montessori built her approach from close observation of children and the conviction that the hand is the chief teacher of the brain. Children learn best through concrete, physical work, in a room scaled and arranged for them, with materials that isolate one idea at a time.
Children choose their own work within limits, moving through the materials at their own pace, often in mixed age groups where older children teach younger ones. The teacher prepares the environment and observes, giving a lesson when it is needed and then stepping back rather than interrupting concentration.
What it does well
- Independence and self direction, practised every day.
- Concentration, protected rather than broken up by an adult’s schedule.
- Order, sequence, and care for tools and materials.
- Confidence that comes from finishing something real without help.
What to weigh
- Much of the day is individual or parallel work, so there is less built in negotiation with a group.
- The approach leans on a child’s readiness to settle and to follow a presented lesson. Ask what happens with a child who resists.
- Expressive and imaginative play sit differently here than in the other two.
One approach
Waldorf
Rhythm, imagination and practical work, with childhood protected.
Waldorf sees early childhood as a stage to be protected rather than accelerated. Days and weeks run on a steady rhythm, with seasonal themes, festivals, stories, baking, sewing, building and long stretches of imaginative play, much of it outdoors and in nature.
The adult is more visibly directing than in Reggio or Montessori, choosing the themes and modelling the work. The materials children meet are deliberately simple so that imagination has to do the rest. Formal reading and writing are usually introduced later.
What it does well
- A rich imaginative life, and unhurried time to live inside it.
- Practical skill and care, learned through real everyday work.
- A felt sense of season and nature.
- Strong social cohesion, because the group shares the same rhythm.
What to weigh
- More adult directed, which some children thrive in and others find tight.
- Later formal literacy and numeracy, which some families welcome and others do not.
- Some schools carry a philosophical or spiritual frame. Ask how much of it reaches the classroom.
Why it matters now
What the next twenty years may ask of them
None of these approaches was designed with artificial intelligence in mind. Each of them, though, builds things that machines do poorly, and the real question for a family is where each one puts its hours.
01
Sustained attention
Any answer is now a tap away. The capacity to stay with a question long after the first easy answer, and to sit with not knowing for a while, is becoming rarer and more valuable at the same time.
02
Forming the question
When answers are cheap, the valuable act moves upstream, to noticing what is worth asking. That is learned by following a curiosity with an adult who takes it seriously, and by being asked what you think.
03
Making something with your hands
Physical material resists you. It teaches judgement, patience and the gap between an idea and what it actually becomes, in a way a screen never can.
04
Doing it with other people
Most of what will matter is still done with others: persuading, listening, disagreeing well, carrying a shared project through. It is also the hardest thing to practise alone.
All three agree on more than the labels suggest: unhurried time, adults who observe rather than interrupt, play taken seriously, and the outdoors treated as part of the day rather than a break from it.
Where the three differ is in how much of the day is given to these. Montessori protects concentration and independence more deliberately than the others, and a child who leaves with the habit of deep, self directed work carries something durable. Waldorf gives imagination and practical craft more room than either, and asks children to make their own pictures rather than receive them ready made. Reggio puts the most weight on the co constructed project: a group of children following one question for weeks, documenting it, arguing about it, and representing it in more than one material.
That last combination is our own reading of where the future is heading, not a verdict on the other two. The work that resists automation tends to be collaborative, open ended and physical, and the Reggio habit of treating children as researchers with real questions is the closest fit we know of for it. Every approach here can produce a capable child. What differs is the practice they get most of, day after day.
Before you choose
The approach matters less than the room
Two centres can share a name and feel nothing alike. On a visit, these are the questions worth asking, whichever approach is printed on the brochure.
- 01How much of the day is child led, and what happens when a child’s interest runs past the plan?
- 02How do you document what children are learning, and can we see an example?
- 03How long do educators stay, and what is your ratio through the day?
- 04What does a child do here on a morning when everything is hard?
- 05How much time is outdoors, in every season?
There is no best approach. There is a best fit.
The three differ in where they put their hours, and your own child will tell you more than any comparison can. If you would like to experience our Reggio-inspired approach at Atelier Kids, come and spend an hour with us.
Written with reference to Daycare Decision: Which Approach is Best for Your Child? and the Our Kids guide to types of preschool programs.

